The math of extra payments
Interest is calculated on remaining principal every month. Pay an extra $200 in year 2 of a 30-year loan and you erase $200 of principal that would have accrued interest for 28 more years.
That compounding-against-you-not-happening is where the savings come from. It's identical math to compound investing — just running in your favor.
The four extra-payment strategies
Monthly extra: simplest, most flexible. Pick an amount and add it to every payment.
Bi-weekly: 13 monthly payments per year instead of 12. Hands-off acceleration.
Annual extra payment: send one extra full payment each year, usually January.
Lump sum from bonus/refund: rare but powerful — earliest dollars matter most.
Recast vs shorten
Default behavior: extras shorten the loan, monthly payment stays the same.
Recast: for a small fee, the lender re-amortizes the loan with the new lower balance — your monthly payment drops, but the savings are smaller than just letting the loan shorten.
Pick shorten unless you actively need lower monthly cash flow.
Extra payment vs invest
Math: compare your mortgage rate to your after-tax expected investment return.
Below 5%: investing usually wins long-term.
Above 6.5%: extra payments usually win.
5.5–6.5%: muddy. Many people split 50/50.
Don't ignore the behavioral angle — guaranteed savings feels different from variable returns. That matters.
Common extra-payment mistakes
- Not specifying "apply to principal" — payment gets credited to next month.
- Paying extra before killing higher-rate debt (credit cards, personal loans).
- Recasting when shortening would save more.
- Stretching to pay extra at the cost of retirement contributions.
- Paying extra without an emergency fund.