Why bonuses have two withholding methods.
The IRS calls bonuses "supplemental wages" and gives employers two ways to handle them. The percentage method (flat 22%) is administratively simple — the same rate for everyone, no payroll-system gymnastics. The aggregate method approximates your actual bracket by pretending the bonus is regular wages.
Neither is "right." Both are estimates of what you'll owe. At filing, your bonus is taxed as ordinary income just like your salary, and any over- or under-withholding is reconciled.
Which method withholds more from your bonus?
For most people in the 12% bracket, the flat 22% method over-withholds — meaning you'll see a smaller deposit but get a bigger refund later. For people in the 24% or 32% bracket, the aggregate method usually withholds more.
The calculator above shows both numbers. If you have a strong cash-flow preference, you can request that your employer use the other method, though many payroll systems don't make this easy.
The Social Security wage cap matters at year-end.
Once your year-to-date wages cross $176,100 (2026), no more Social Security is withheld on that year's remaining wages — including bonuses. For high earners getting a Q4 bonus, this can mean 6.2% more in net than the same bonus earlier in the year.
Use the YTD wages field in the calculator to model this accurately.
Legitimate ways to reduce the bonus tax bill.
1) Direct the bonus to your 401(k) (pre-tax). 2) Top up an HSA. 3) Fund an FSA for next plan year if rules allow. 4) Donate to charity in the same calendar year. 5) Bunch deductions (state taxes, mortgage interest) if you can itemize.
These aren't loopholes — they're the same options that work on regular wages, but a bonus is a great time to use them because the dollars are "extra" and easier to set aside.
Common bonus-tax mistakes
- Assuming the 22% flat rate is your actual final tax (it's only withholding).
- Treating the bonus like windfall income — at filing time, it's identical to salary.
- Forgetting state withholding, especially in CA/NY where supplemental rates are higher.
- Missing the Social Security wage cap if the bonus is paid late in the year.
- Not directing the bonus to a 401(k) when you're still under the annual limit.
- Spending the full gross before the actual deposit hits — net is always lower.