Physical vacancy vs economic vacancy.
Most beginner pro formas pick a vacancy number out of the air — 5% feels right, write it down, move on. The problem is that 5% is usually a physical-vacancy figure, which measures empty days as a share of total days. It says nothing about what happens during a move-out.
Economic vacancy folds in everything that erodes your rent roll: lost rent during turnover, paint and cleaning, marketing, screening, and any move-in concessions or first-month-free deals you offered. For the same property, economic vacancy is almost always 2–4 percentage points higher than physical vacancy. Run the calculator above and you can see the gap directly.
What vacancy rates actually look like in the market.
Across the US, residential vacancy generally runs between 5% and 10%, with most stabilized properties in the 6–8% band. Hot markets like Austin and Boise have dipped below 4% during bull cycles; secondary markets and college towns regularly run 10–12% during the summer.
Use these as a starting point, not a target. Your actual number depends on asset class (Class A apartments turn over faster than Class C), management style (responsive landlords lose fewer days), and pricing strategy (push rent and you push vacancy too). The "8% market" preset in the calculator is a defensible midpoint when you have no other data.
The hidden cost of turnover.
A common mistake is treating turnover as free because it only happens between tenants. It is not free. A typical single-family or apartment turnover involves paint ($300–$600), deep cleaning ($150–$300), marketing and screening ($100–$300), and minor repairs ($200–$500). Bundle those with 2–4 weeks of empty rent and the all-in cost easily clears $1,500–$3,000.
That number changes how you think about everything else. A tenant who renews at flat rent for a second year is saving you the entire turnover cost — easily worth a 2–3% rent concession to keep them. The "annual turnover per unit" slider in the calculator lets you see this directly: drop it from 1.0 to 0.5 and watch true effective income jump.
Why lenders underwrite at 7–10% — and you should too.
When a bank or DSCR lender sizes your loan, they don't trust your 3% pro forma vacancy. They substitute their own — typically 7% for stabilized residential, 10% for newer or non-stabilized assets. They are not being pessimistic; they are pricing in the trough year of the cycle when sizing debt that has to survive 10 to 30 years.
Adopt the lender's lens from day one. Build your initial model at 7–10% vacancy, not the 3% you saw at the top of a hot rental cycle. If the deal cash flows at the lender's number, you have a financeable, durable property. If it only works at sub-5%, you have a thesis, not a deal.
Longer leases vs higher rent: the real tradeoff.
- Every avoided turnover saves you $1,500–$3,000 plus 2–4 weeks of vacancy.
- A flat renewal beats a 6% bump that triggers a turnover, in most years.
- In markets with strong rent growth (>5% YoY), short leases preserve upside but cost you in turnover.
- Push rent only when you have a backup applicant ready and turnover time can be compressed to under 14 days.
- Long-term tenants who pay slightly below market are an asset, not a missed opportunity — they're a vacancy hedge.